Businesses get recommended by ChatGPT and Google AI Overviews when three things are true: their website clearly explains what they do, for whom and where; trusted sites across the web mention them in the same way; and their pages are easy for search engines to crawl and quote. You can't pay for a spot in an AI answer, but you can make your business the obvious one to name.
Here's a step-by-step plan, with the reasoning behind each step.
How AI tools decide who to recommend
AI assistants answer questions by drawing on content they find on the web, then summarizing it. Google's AI Overviews and AI Mode pull from Google's index and show supporting links. Google says the usual SEO best practices apply, and that a page must be indexed and eligible for a snippet to appear as a supporting link (Google Search Central).
Google's guide to optimizing for generative AI features also says content people find unique, compelling and useful is likely to matter more over time than any other tactic. In other words: be the clearest, most credible source on your topic.
Step 1: Make your website say exactly what you do
AI tools struggle with vague marketing copy. Make every key fact plain text on your site:
- What you sell, in the words customers use ("scaffolding rental", not "vertical access solutions").
- Who you serve and where ("for contractors in New York City, New Jersey and Connecticut").
- Proof: years in business, clients, results, certifications, prices or price ranges.
- One page per service, each answering the questions buyers ask.
Step 2: Answer the questions people ask AI
List 20 questions a buyer might type into ChatGPT, such as "best commercial scaffolding supplier in NYC" or "who sells banana flakes in bulk in the USA". Then make sure your site answers each one directly, near the top of a relevant page, in a few clear sentences. Use FAQs, comparison tables and short definitions.
This is where AEO and GEO overlap; see AEO vs GEO vs AI SEO.
Step 3: Get mentioned on sites AI trusts
AI answers lean on sources beyond your own site. Work on:
- Reviews on Google and industry review sites.
- Directory and marketplace listings with consistent name, address and services.
- Industry press and trade publications.
- Partner, supplier and association pages that list you.
- Comparison and "best of" articles in your category.
For local businesses, a strong Google Business Profile is one of the most important sources.
Step 4: Fix the technical basics
- Allow search engines to crawl your important pages (check robots.txt and any firewall or CDN settings).
- Keep key content in text, not only in images, PDFs or scripts.
- Use internal links so every service page is easy to find.
- Add structured data (Organization, LocalBusiness, Service, FAQ) to make facts machine-readable.
Step 5: Test what AI says about you
Once a month, ask ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini and Google (AI Mode or AI Overviews) your top 10 buyer questions. Record:
| Question | Are you named? | Who is named instead? | Which sources are cited? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Best [service] in [city] | |||
| [Service] cost in [city] |
The cited sources tell you where to focus. If a directory or article keeps appearing, get listed there.
Step 6: Measure the traffic
Traffic from ChatGPT and Perplexity usually appears as referral traffic in analytics. Google includes clicks from its AI features in normal Search Console totals. Track leads from these sources, not just visits.
A real example
A tri-state scaffolding supplier used this approach to become the vendor AI names first in NYC. The case study walks through what was done and the results.
FAQ
Can I pay to be recommended by ChatGPT? No. Organic AI answers aren't sold. You earn mentions through clear content and a strong reputation.
How long does it take to appear in AI answers? It varies. Changes to your own site can be picked up as soon as pages are recrawled; off-site reputation takes months to build.
Does this work for local businesses in New York? Yes. Local businesses often have the best odds because the competition for "in [neighborhood]" questions is smaller. See AI SEO for NYC Businesses.
Is this different from SEO? It's SEO with extra focus on clarity, facts and off-site mentions.
Get an AI visibility audit
See how the AI SEO Consultant service works in New York and beyond, or book a free AI SEO audit to see who AI recommends in your category today.